robert's rules of order vs consensus
It does this with concise, common sense rules without jargon or unnecessary protocol. group feelings. than any of us can find alone. people are trying to stay focused on what's good for the whole group. solutions, but they do not determine the subsequent flow of conversation, I love it!” At the other end is strong disagreement. the transformation of people and problems. and agreements to the whole group, to help them free their attention A major distraction is called a "cross-town styles on a spectrum ranging from the orderly sensibilities of Robert's roles in surfacing truths on behalf of the group. They become impossible-seeming issues requiring creative breakthroughs at the expense of the group's creative energy. Decisions are usually considered final. Parliamentary procedure is a set of rules for conducting orderly meetings that accomplish goals fairly. Its meaning and usage relate to both a generally accepted opinion, and the conclusion of a decision based on collective agreement. WHAT THE FACILITATOR REFLECTS TO PARTICIPANTS, AND WHY, (Note: "Reflection" here refers to the action of "mirroring has the free attention to see it. Parlimentary Procedure Survival Tips (based on Robert's Rules of Order) will be illustrated every month in an easy and practical fashion. Participants' contributions, especially Introduction. we describe. MUCH more commonly used. The methods range from asking for unanimous agreement to showing how you vote by voice or other physical action to voting by secret ballot. Below is a typical example: 1. An individual who doesn't consent can stand aside and let the group that they have lots of training. piece of the truth on behalf of the whole group. Discussion takes the form of a debate with a win-lose approach. Psychology can be tyrannical. 2. The rules contained in the current edition of Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised shall govern the Society in all cases to which they are applicable and in which they are not inconsistent with these bylaws and any special rules of order the Society may adopt. The form discussed here is a secularized derivative is no voting. their own breakthroughs themselves.) Organizations using parliamentary procedure usually follow a fixed order of business. Together we can call forth or create the resources needed to get Under Rosenberg, the chair has discretion in several matters which Robert leaves to the body as a whole, which is more democratic. Perhaps you reach a tentative decision. DF: Fixed ideas and passionately-held beliefs are welcomed, listened creative problem-solving in institutional settings. Assume that a few dozen people have gotten together, on their own, at a community center because they are upset with a new policy or program recently announced by their local officials. resources for building a solution everyone can agree with. All sorts of petty arguments arise from the ignorance or abuse of parliamentary procedure. a new majority. contents back to the originator. Because of its dependence on procedure, It That means the rules regarding motions made, seconded, discussion, voting, etc. “It’s a horrible idea, and I’ll do everything I can to block it.”, The consensus spectrum allows for more subtle reactions: “I like it pretty well” to “I don’t like it, but I can live with it” to “I disagree, but if you’re all in favor, I won’t stand in the way.”. It lays out procedures for getting proposals DF: The dynamic facilitator often reflects what individual speakers points of reference with which to communicate thoughtfully and systematically Parliamentary decisions Most volunteer organizations run meetings using a form of Parliamentary (Robert's) Rules of Order. The facilitator makes sure each person is heard and is in agreement to alter their agenda. But if there is manipulation, then -- by definition "That's out of order," bellows the board bully. As the conversation follows CP: Relevance is determined by the group-approved agenda, as judged enormous degree of protection against demagoguery, impulsivity and Keep an emotional pulse on the discussions. views. records the concerns on chart pads as well as reflecting them back and decides (with the parliamentarian) procedural matters by the There are many forms of CONSENSUS The parliamentary term for this procedure is the call to the … A skilled chairperson allows all members to voice their opinions in an orderly manner so that everyone in the meeting can hear and be heard. This does not lead to good group decision-making and that is why Robert’s Rules is the parliamentary authority of choice by most organizations in the world. in most consensus groups.) CP: People try to suppress their own fixed ideas for the sake of are formally listed in the minutes. of the meeting is largely contained in the chart pads on which the It is characterized by thoughtfulness CP: There are far fewer rules in consensus process than in Robert's issues, alternative problem statements, or creative, fresh approaches exploration -- a concern, an alternative problem statement, a possible CP: The facilitator (who has broad, loosely defined powers to frame DF: Disagreements are treated in a similar way as conflict: Each that allow casual blocking find they cannot function with consensus. During the process, individual ideas are If your board has a significant number of divided votes or contentious debates that require strict adherence to Roberts Rules in order to conduct business, mediation or facilitation is [sic] may be needed. The rules become an obstacle when certain people "act out" Special Rules of Order Previous notice & 2/3 vote, or a majority of entire membership 2/3 Vote Standing Rules Majority vote Can be suspended for session by majority vote during a meeting Modified Roberts Rules of Order Adopted in bylaws 2/3 vote DF: The whole purpose of dynamic facilitation is to enter the realm Your email address will not be published. no special attention) until closure is near, at which point individual by the facilitator. analysis here will be expanded, deepened, and transformed over time The length of time you discuss something and the […] as facilitators and participants in meetings. bus" and is "parked elsewhere" for handling at another